The academic year of 2016/2017 was the first in which Progress 8 and Attainment 8 were introduced to ensure all students were studying a broad and balanced curriculum. This is to place emphasis on students' progress and make sure they are working to their full potential. With a focus on this, we weigh out the pros and cons below.
All students are pushed to their full potential
By measuring a school’s overall attainment for all pupils, focus is shifted from the number of students achieving a C grade and above. This means that all students should receive equal attention and be pushed to their full potential as opposed to the focus being on the C/D borderline students.
All subjects receive the same amount of attention
As results are no longer broken down by specific subjects and instead attainment is measured over a combination of 8, equal attention will be given to all subjects students are studying as all grades achieved could add to a student’s overall Attainment 8 score.
Students are encouraged to study a broad curriculum
Due to the fact that all slots in Buckets 2 and 3 (Ebacc subjects and ‘Other’ subjects) have to be filled, students at GCSE level will be encouraged to study a wider variety of subjects, because if not all slots are filled from the buckets, a score of 0 will be awarded for that slot.
Creative subjects aren’t given enough attention
Not enough emphasis is put on creative subjects in the new structure. At first glance it appears as though the ‘Other’ slot caters for these subjects, however when you find out that these slots can be filled by Ebacc subjects and English it undermines the importance of the creative subjects.
Students’ individual learning needs aren’t accounted for
There are concerns that Progress 8 scores don’t take into account the variety of students in a school such as those who are SEN, EAL, PP or those that are in areas of deprivation.
Extra pressure on high achievers at KS2
Students who achieved a high attainment score at KS2 could be under a lot of pressure to increase their Attainment 8 score at GCSE despite performing at the higher end of the scale, as they would have to work at getting the very top grades to ensure they have a positive Progress 8 score.
*The threat of outliers was previously a con to the new accountability measures but provisions introduced in 2018 mean steps have been taken to counteract this concern.